Ricki, Yes, and music is very subjective, it doesn't make us right either if we say something sucks. There's a lot of hit music I think sucks too.

We do all spend too Much time here, and some people never enter a song thread.

But the way you describe how critiques should be is not how it happens in the real world.

You could pick the greatest song ever and visit YouTube and see 10 k thumbs down, and comments that you wouldn't even say on a construction site.

But what does this is a great theme, or you captured this part well, but the bridge might be off, really mean?

Does that say anything about how good the song is? What it really means is you have found a way to be nice about something that is not very good.

If you loved the song, you wouldn't say it needed anything. You'd be in awe and listening to it over and over again.

It means your expecting amateur songs right from the get go.

I'm amazed at how much stuff is called great here.

The value of the word great weakens when u see it in every single thread.








Last edited by Fdemetrio; 08/11/18 12:03 PM.