Firstly, Knute it's a compulsory license.

Secondly, No, artists/labels should charge based on demand for their products, not some lowball number based on what some marketing guy says is the 'buy' point for single songs. People will decide what the right price is for any particular song, when they are offered as individual units as opposed to 'albums', and artists can be free to ignore that price if they wish to.

Kit, what your model ignores is the distinction between the recording art and the performing art. In my case the recorded product is the end-all. It's value as a component of my income shouldn't be eroded or destroyed because of its online proliferation through file-'sharers'. Indeed I should be able to make a handsome income solely from my recordings if that is my desire.

Nobody seems to be talking about SONGWRITERS, as the running presumption is that the songwriter IS the performer. If I'm the songwriter but NOT the performer, that file-'sharing' DL deprives me of pub money, with no way of ever getting paid for public live OR recorded performances of MY WORK!

As a songwriting artist, I shouldn't need to be making a living from hawking graphic-artist-designed-logo t-shirts and ballcaps supposedly somehow representing my musical art like some swap-meet Tommy Hilfiger. I note that at the concerts I've attended, that merch is wildly almost deludedly overpriced when compared to cost, but I don't hear any hue-and-cry ANYwhere that bands need to drop price on merch or folks are gonna print their own and swap it with their friends and the rest of the world!

------------------
edx.iuma.com www.soundclick.com/40LOVE www.soundclick.com/EdX

[This message has been edited by ed323 (edited 09-15-2003).]