RobertK--

Thank you for your reply on this--very interesting and just the kind of thoughtful response I was hoping for!

I would like to add something: I'm a music lover. I also enjoy words and language. There are people who love words more than I do--poets, novelists, writers of all kinds. I would guess that to some of them, words could be more important than music in their lives.

In a poem, words are everything. (Well, delivery counts, too. Some people can take a poem and recite it in a way that is just amazing, using skills related to acting.)

I hope it was clear in my original post that I was referring to the relative importance of music and words IN A SONG, not comparing their value in general.

I think it's really cool how words and music can work together for us to make something different from music or words alone. We have poetry, we have music, we have songs--all sort of unique, all very creative endeavors. I'm also glad we as people can enjoy things that we can't do--like other people's poetry or music or songs! It must be thrilling for both parties when a great lyricist and a great composer who admire each other's work get together and create a wonderful song.

I guess that's partly what JPF tries to facilitate. I'm probably never going to experience that since any lyrics that come out of me are already attached to music, but I'm glad for other people who are able to find each other and create something as a team. Thank you, Brian!

--Jean

[This message has been edited by JL (edited 02-13-2004).]