I don't think I would automatically lump self released musical works into the "vanity publishing" category. At least, not with the negative connotations implied here.

I can think of a couple of artists, off hand, whose "vanity publishing" garnered them plenty of attention and money. Whether they made it onto the beloved Billboard charts, I'm not sure. If not, I can't imagine they were too troubled by it. Nothing like cold hard cash and international recognition to salve the ego.

Most musicians, writers, etc. only dream of being able to support themselves solely through their musical endeavors. There are plenty who do so through such so-called "vanity publishing". Is there some different criteria for success that applies to these people, or should we arbitrarily demean them while we continue working our full time jobs, squeezing in a little writing and playing as time allows?

This whole assinine argument about the relative value of music versus lyrics has been very engrossing. I'm always amazed at the conviction and fervor a person can bring to a subject that is, in essence, nothing short of subjective. Maybe someday I will be good enough at either musical composition, lyric writing, or both, that I will become as enamored with myself and my opinions as seems to be the case with some evidently "not-so-plain folks" here. Something to strive for, I suppose.

I will keep my eyes peeled for the "chicken or the egg" thread, so I can follow that one, too.