I wonder if there are debates about what is more important to the Reeses Peanut Butter Cup...the chocolate or the peanut butter ?

Does it matter..?

I think not...

Is there any way to determine which is more responsible for the success of the product..

I don't think so...

If you asked most people which they thought was more essential to the success of the cup..they might have an opinion...

Some folks like peanut butter more than chocolate, some vice versa...
But...they work really well together....so.....who the Hell cares.....what's the difference ?

Music is subjective....

If you want to believe the music is the key...well...that's fine...
If you think the words are the key....that's fine too.

but can you ever say without a doubt that one is more "important"...that either is the "essential" ingredient...

No...no you can't.

My opinions on the matter are based largely on experience in dealing with popular music...

I can go on stage and play a pattern over and over...the same three chords.....
It will soon become tedious and monotonous..the listeners WILL tune out...
BUT...if I add words to that repeating pattern..they will reinvolve the listener
The song Johnny B Goode was brought up....
I can sing that song and play it's accompanying pattern of chords and people will sing along and dance..
I can continue playing the same "driving" pattern with no words and they'll sit back down and ignore me...OR..I can start singing one of a thousand other songs that fit the same musical feel and pattern and VIOLA ! they're back with me again !

That's why my opinion is that it's the words that connect the listener to the song.

That's my opinion, and the experience that fuels my logic.

I don't think that a musician or entertainer will step up and disagree with that idea.
I'll certainly be surprised if one does.

Many contemporary bands are comprised of musicians with very mediocre musical abilities.
Imagine REM songs without the words...perish the thought.....
I like REM...I think the songs are thoughtful and interesting...but...the music is pretty weak in my opinion...
The idea of listening to those tracks without the great words..well...I don't think so....

So the point is moot.....

There is no formula for determining which matters most..
Examples can be made of songs that were carried by the lyrics..(Bob Dylans hits come to mind)
There are certainly examples of inane mumblings carried to glory on the back of great music (how about Whole Lotta Love by Led Zeppelin)

But to imply that one is always more important than the other.....
Well.....that's just silly !

Bob Young