Just a reply to some of Robert's points. The next time you go to a sold out concert of Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, Kenny Chesney, etc., see how people can tell you who wrote the music (or the lyrics).

It doesn't matter if they don't know the name of the songwriters - they know the MUSIC. The crowd is swaying, clapping, stomping, etc. to the sound of instruments and voices, and only secondarily (if at all) focused on the lyrics. The performance and the sound, that's what's putting the fannies in the seats, not the words.

But before we lionize composers, let's compare the number of people who go to hear symphonies to the number who go listen to rap music. If instrumental music was such a hot item, there would be more than one station per city playing it.

Missing the point, again - why does "music is more important" have to mean "no words at all"? Composers mean those who write music, whether it's to a symphony or to a pop hit.

Often the singing of the words is almost as if another instrument is being enjoyed, that instrument being the human voice, without people paying attention to or absorbing the specific words. Otherwise how can you explain the success of songs like Con Te Partiro (aka, Time To Say Goodbye) - I'm sure the vast majority of the people who made that song a hit on both sides of the Atlantic don't understand Italian, but are nonetheless mesmerized by the voices of Brightman and Bocelli. And when you read a translation of the words, assuming you have a burning need to understand the lyric, you'll find it's actually quite trite.

And if you think the listeners to rap are getting off on the gobbledy-gook being spoken/sung rather than the voices as percussive instruments themselves, the driving relentless beat and the electricity of the performers and the crowd, well...



[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-13-2004).]