Yeah the subject of which is more important, lyrics or music has come up many times on this and other boards. But wasn't the original post on this thread thus: "I'm a little confused by quite a few posts I've read where people ask for critiques of a "song" they've written--and it turns out to be just words"? With that alone in mind as opposed to the lyrics vs. music argument I must admit that I've often been puzzled by how one can call a lyric that has not been put to music a song.

Now if a lyricist who doesn't play an instrument has a head tune to the lyric at the time of writing the lyric surely it is indeed a song because it does have a melody, the quality of the melody being another matter. They are posting on a lyric critique site and are asking for feedback on the lyric itself. Perhaps later they will find a collaborator who will work with them and compose a new melody or an improvement of the head tune the lyricist had when writing. In that case it is still a song but with a different melody.

My question and the one I believe the original poster was posing is concerning a lyricist who posts a lyric that was written with no intention of a melody, probably hoping someone who composes music/melody will take an interest somewhere along the line and add music/melody. In this case I don't see how the lyric can be correctly designated a song. It might be an excellent lyric that really cries out for added music making it a complete song but at that point is it not merely a prospective part of what might end up being a song? I think that is the distinction of the question posed. And of course, unless I am familiar with the lyricist him/herself and know they only write lyrics from a form or rhythmic perspective I have no way of knowing if there is at least a head tune involved at all. Or if they clue us in when they post the lyric.

I guess it is equally true that a composer with a piece of music that cries out for lyric content is not yet a song either but an instrumental piece, piece of music or however it should properly be designated at that point. When that musical piece is married to words it would then be a true song. That is what makes sense to me concerning the original question here. Anyway that's my take. The argument of which is more important, lyric or music/melody it seems to me, is another mater altogether.

Steve Biederman


I'm the only person here who is not unique.