10,000 units, while nothing to sneeze at and for all told a nice accomplishment when one doesn't have the backing of a major label or promotional force, is still not enough of a track record to sneer at others and make left-handed comments about their musical efforts (especially since it has nothing to do with the topic at hand, and while I too could point to some successes with my own work, it's just bad form to bring it up in such a manner).

Vanity publishing is the term which refers to most 'independent' releases which are initiated and paid for by the artist(s) releasing said CD (or the label created by said artist(s). Its signature trait is that most sales are garnered when the artist(s) play at public venues and the enthusiastic audience avails themselves of the CD being offered then and there. Many on-the-road acts make a fair living thereby, and I myself have purchased such CD's, the most recent one being a rockabilly rouser by Ray Condo and his Ricochets after he played in a small club in the area and made 100 people sound like a crowd of 1000 - I handed the money to the bass player himself, but I digress.

I didn't really want to get side-tracked by the discussion of "mine's bigger than yours", I only replied to your initial snide barbs about not having heard or seen my creative efforts, which to be frank, shouldn't even have come into play, since they really have nothing to do with whose opinion carries more weight: a la the critic versus the actor.

Many centuries ago some Greek philosophers addressed the question of "can those who can't do a thing make a valid evaluation of the efforts of those who can", to paraphrase.

The answer was yes, for the simple reason that (again an analogy, not the specific reply):

Though one might not be able to play a note on the violin, one can surely tell when one is being played poorly.

Anyway, feel free to show this discussion to your friend (though I'm surprised you'd care to make the effort).

Of course, as we all realize, when it comes to these boards, alas, one extra opinion on this matter, no matter how educated, is pretty much not going to change anyone's mind.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

After all was said and done, more was said than done.



[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 03-02-2004).]