RobertK..

I've been insulted many times..

that's OK..

But you're just so Completely wrong headed that it's hard to take you seriously.

I was there when Chuck Berry was first coming along..
First of all, you should know that Chuck didn't have any monster hits in his early days.
Johnny B Goode barely cracked the top 10.
Sweet little 16 and so many more languished in the mid to upper top 40.
The songs have become classics over time..

Their key to success is ALL about the words...the music is run of the mill Rhythm and Blues,.
It haed been around for years..hell..Chucks signature lick goes back to Louis Jordans guitar player (can't think of his name) from back in the early 40's.

Much of what "is" in music is that way because it used to be that way.

Music is a real conservative art form, especially "popular" music.

There certainly was a time when instrumental music was more important and more commercially successful than vocal music.

That time has passed.

Eventually musicologists will catch up.

Those of us that live by what music is and not what it purports to be (like you, I'm afraid) have caught up to the logic already.

A 45 year career 5 years at a time..hmmmmm..interesting concept,,, but I think my current audience would not find my machinations of 45 years ago very entertaing.

I do suggest that I just may have learned something on this road.

It has been said by others on this thread that determining which is essential to the success of a piece (words or music) is impossible.

I agree...once a song has moved into the "hit" area it becomes an impossibiblity to credit the words or the music as the key ingredient.

If you asked Elton if he could go back and write all that music to someone other than Bernie Taupins words but that he would have to live by the result...
I'm sure Elton would say "Thanks but no thanks"

And I think Rainy Day Women was a fine song...it's part of my acoustic act and people young and old love it...and you know what...I play the chords all wrong..nothinkg like Dylans, and they don't knowe the difference.
They all know how to sing "Everybody MUST Get Stoned" and that's all they care about.

God Bless 'Em..
They've got it right..

My advice is..
Take a lesson from them.

And try some Decaf for Crissakes !

Bob (still smiling) Young