Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by NHolbrook:
Hello Everyone, I am a lyricist/songwriter whatever you want to call me. I write words first. I do write the music also, but I prefer others to do that for me. Just to keep the argument going, I do know of a song for which the lyrics are more important than the music, in fact I would be willing to say that the song could've been cut without music and still would've had nationwide impact and still been a #1. The song is Alan Jackson's "Where Were You". Listen to that song again and tell me the words aren't more important. I am not a biased person, I simply think we all feel that out part(s) of whatever are more important than others. We think this because we are human. I appreciate all music and all genres. In fact, I usually write my country lyrics while listening to rap. I'm just a weird duck. I just believe that music and words are usually both required of a song to make it great. Would that #1 hit still be #1 if it didn't have words? The same goes if it didn't have music... This is the never-ending discussion where there is not real right answer. Thanks for reading.

</font>


I can't believe any song would be released as a single never mind become a hit with no music. In country music the lyric is king (even though there are plenty of hit country songs with very cliche and unoriginal lyrics) however, without music and melody you don't have a song and no publisher artist, etc., will give you the time of day. At either the ASCAP or BMI website there is a link to a round table discussion with Nashville Publishers and the number one most important thing they were looking for was a great lyric followed by a great melody. There have been songs with no lyrics which have been hits, such as songs by Kenny G and Edgar Winter and songs with no instruments like "Don't worry be happy" but never a song with no melody. The official definition of a song includes the word poem, but in the real world a song contains music and/or melody and 99% of the time lyrics. Lyrics alone are words on a paper not a song, no matter how we spin it.

[This message has been edited by Ynot (edited 02-27-2004).]