Lyricists are respected and composers are lionized. Good defensive shortstops are respected and sluggers are lionized. All that proves is that the public--those who do the lionizing--don't know much about either music or baseball. The truth is that each element all critically important to the team. Sometimes Sammy Sosa wins the game. Sometimes it's Ozzie Smith.

It proves that, what the SS does is worth about $3M/yr, assuming he can hit at least .275, and what the slugger does is worth $13M+/yr.

Each element is NOT critically important, otherwise...

Side note: The baseball analogy between defense/offense and words/music is not a bad one.

The .275 hitting defensive magicians would be paid the same as the .300+, 40 HR+, 100 RBI+ sluggers or the 20 victory a year pitchers.

They're not, and it has nothing to do with the public's lack of baseball savvy. It has to do with excitement and who's putting the fans in the seats. (And the fact that, no matter how solid your defense and pitching, if you can't score runs you're going to struggle for every win, whereas monster offense will cover a lot of defensive holes - there's a reason folks say "The best defense is a good offense".

And often we hear about an offensive player "carrying a team", sometimes for weeks at a time - when was the last time a defensive star received the same accolade?

Same with lyricist and composer.

There are plenty of great hits with so-so and even poor lyrics, but I can't think of too many great lyrics that carried mediocre tunes.

Let's revisit my previous challenge. Take a popular song that has 'great lyrics', i.e., where the lyrics are allegedly more important than the music, and see how many people can sing the lyrics to any great extent, even though having heard the song innumerable times.

If the lyrics are what are allegedly 'selling' certain songs, then people would be able to recall them as quickly as the more mediocre music for a given "great lyrics" song, right?

Aside from the Star Spangled Banner and Happy Birthday (or that interminable American Pie), the words, even the 'great lyrics' are not remembered by many, even the more astute listeners.

I reiterate: this is not to say that words mean nothing. The combination of great music and words make magic indeed, the bedrock of much of what survives the test of time.

But it's still the music that brings the most to the table.

[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-13-2004).]