Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by Ynot:


I wasn't harping on you, only stating that there have been hit songs with no lyrics, but never a hit song with no melody..
</font>



Actually, this is not quite true. Songs without melodies (called recitations) were once rather common, especially in country music. There was a whole sub-genre of "truck driver" songs where recitations were very popular. Porter Waggoner and Bill Anderson used to do a lot of recitations, too.

I can only think of a couple recent examples of a no-melody hits. One was a huge hit that I cannot remember the name of, or the artist, but it was a hit 2 or 3 years ago and it was like a commencement speech, with some stuff about using sunscreen, spoken over a music bed. Alan Jackson also had a recitation hit last year or maybe the year before that. I cannot remember the name of it. Certainly someone will want to claim that these records HAD MUSIC, and that is true, but they HAD NO MELODY, and that is the point.