It is interesting to me that many of you have responded that the melody is the hard part, or at least harder than lyrics. I find coming up with catchy music is a piece of cake. I can typically come up with a couple of melodies an evening, and hooks are easy. But I'm lucky if I can come up with 3 or 4 decent sets of lyrics a year. Yet many of you are implying that lyricists are a dime a dozen.

Of course, maybe it is how we define a decent set of lyrics. Many of the lyrics I've heard or read, even for "hit" songs, either don't say anything or say the same thing as many others have said many times before and are rather trite. Maybe we have different standards for what is a decent set of lyrics and what is a decent melody. To me, what makes either the melody or lyrics decent is that I find myself wanting to play or say them repeatedly. If I catch myself doing it unconsciously, that's even better. Using this test, many "lyrics" fail miserably.

For me, I don't really have to make an effort to write music for good lyrics. With good lyrics, the music automatically comes just in reading the lyrics, due to the phrasing of the lyrics, where the accented and strong words fall, rhyming patterns, the syllable counts, etc. If the lyrics aren't already suggesting a melody, then maybe the lyrics need improvement.

------------------
Stone Marmot
www.stonemarmot.com
Stone Marmot on Soundclick
Alternative pop-rock music:
Definitely rock, somewhat pop, but a bit more experimental.


Stone Marmot
http://www.stonemarmot.com
Alternative pop-rock music:
Definitely rock, somewhat pop, but a bit more experimental.