and your refusal to accept that "sometimes" the lyric is more important, is just argumentative, rather than sincere.

Sheesh. Throughout these posts I've allowed that "sometimes" the lyric is more important.

The main dispute was with the statement that "sometimes" the music is more important, to which I maintained the "vast majority" of the time the music was more important.

Since you want to throw around words like "silliness" and such (who's being argumentative?), let me repost some of the quotes of my previous posts:

I reiterate: this is not to say that words mean nothing. The combination of great music and words make magic indeed, the bedrock of much of what survives the test of time.

But it's still the music that brings the most to the table.


Note "most" <> "all".

Well, I didn't think I'd have to keep belaboring the obvious by saying TRUE, nothing is ALWAYS the case, but my point all along is that you're wrong when you say SOMETIMES, because the vast majority of the time it is, just like SOMETIMES a great defensive play wins a game, but MOST of the time it's hitting or passing or running.

Note that "vast majority of the time" does allow that "sometimes" the opposite can occur (namely, lyrics carry the music).

And if you think it's "silly" to say that in the rap and hip-hop genres it's not the words that carry the song, but the driving rhythm of the song and the excitement of the crowd and dynamics of the performer, next time you're in a room of people frenetically jumping up and down to the likes of one of the latest hits, as soon as the song is over, ask a few of the folks to repeat even two lines of what they just heard. (I'd try the experiment myself, but I'd look "silly" in such a club).

Maybe it's biased of me to even say it, but using rap and hip-hop as an argument for the importance of lyrics over music is beyond silly.

And for some of the other posters who seem to be harping on 'instrumentals', early on in one of the first posts that issue was answered, to wit:

Missing the point, again - why does "music is more important" have to mean "no words at all"? Composers mean those who write music, whether it's to a symphony or to a pop hit.

It's nice to have 45 years experience, but only if it doesn't appear to be 5 years experience 9 times over.


[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 02-19-2004).]