I don't know Noel.
I call myself a writer. Not a songwriter. Not a lyricist. Not a composer.
I just write.
In the field of songs, I really class myself as a lyricist even though I have written and recorded to demo stage over 100 songs.
And six of the seven cuts I have are my music.
It is the words that most often comes first, and the imprortant bits to me.
One of the cuts I have, I am on the credits as the keyboard player, because the studio used the midi keybopard backing I wrote as was, for the bed track.
This does not make me want to call myself a musician.
Just something that happened along the way.
I don't see any looking down on somebody by calling them a lyricist if they do words only.
If they can take those words and sing, hum , or whistle a tune they fit to, they are a songwriter in my book.
Same as I don't see anything demeaning in someone being called a composer when they only write music.
There are some great instrumentals out there that simply do not lend themselves well to words being sung to them.
You can call a spade a shovel if you like, but that doesn't make it one.
And both have their seperate , yet complimentary parts to play in the scheme of things.
I learned to write music because some of my poems seemed to sing to me, and I couldn't find any musicians to write music to them, even when I did the sing the melody thing on them.
I'm not wonderful at it but am still learning, and have a whole heap of fun doing it.
I spend a lot of time over on JPF theory forum and it has been a veritable feast for me clue wise.
I recommend it to anybody who want to rise above their percieved posision of "just a lyricist."
Graham



------------------
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/2/grahamhendersonmusic.htm