Cisco Kid (GarY) has it right..

(We do grow 'em smart in Illinois !)

A song is lyrics and melody (or melody only)
To be a song (tecnically) there must be some melodic content of some kind..

BUT..

I would certainly agree that if a lyricist wants to call their work a "song", that's fine...there is no law involved,,,they can call it whatever they want...it's really just semantics and something else to occupy our minds so we don't have time to think about dying !

It's fun to see how far we can digress from the original intent of a thread..
I certainly plead guilty...

It's kewl !

Can anybody here sing "Song of Songs" from the Bible ?

I'm hearing a minor kind of deal...maybe..oh...94bpm..with lots of little drum sounds and bells.....

Yeah.....

bob Young