Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by greydog:
Perhaps RobertK can find just one whose "Melody Only" forum gets more usage and hits than its "Lyric Only" forum... or maybe just find a site that even has a "Melody Only" forum.

I suspect you can find "Lyric Only" and "Complete Songs" ... but no "Melody Only"
dawg
</font>


You're making my point for me. One can go out on the internet and literally bathe in the amount of lyrics to be had "for a song", that is, that go a-begging for music.

The rare instance of the occasional composer looking for words is all the more remarkable for it being the vast exception rather than the rule.

There are no "melody only" boards for the same reason there are no demo services or song sharks making a living by offering "LET US PUT WORDS TO YOUR MUSIC!".

This is at least the third time I'm reiterating that the previous posts concern themselves not with "absolutely no words", but rather the relative value of music versus words; having or using no lyrics at all was never part of the debate.

No one ever said "music alone" is preferred when talking about songs, nor did anyone say music is ALWAYS the most important element.

Like I said, as far as "no melodies boards", you're making my point for me: there are hundreds of "songwriting boards" on the internet which feature lyrics only or are vastly dominated by lyrics.

Why? Because everybody and their grandmother is a songwriter; that is, of the type who write 'lyrics only'.

Of course there are no "melodies only" boards because those who can compose either write their own lyrics or find it quite easy to fill the breach from the several dozens of lyrics-only folks who jump at the chance to work with a composer.

Look at it from a truer "which is more important" gauge: go to any lyrics board and look at the number of "lyrics only" posts versus the posts of MP3's with music. There is usually a four to one ratio, and often more.

Oh, and of those MP3 complete songs, subtract the number of songs that were written solely by one person.

Even on the 'hard core' words-and-music songwriting sites there are twice as many lyrics posted as full songs.

Which proves not only that there are more lyricists than composers, but that finding someone to put music to your 'song' (as a true collaborator, not some demo shop service) is a damn sight more difficult than finding someone willing to write words to your music.

It's simple economics: the more common a thing is, the lesser value it has compared to a rarer item.

NOTE THAT THIS DOES NOT MEAN THE COMMON ITEM IS WORTHLESS OR UNNECESSARY!!! (Sorry to shout, but this will be the third or fourth time I've said it during this thread.)


[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 03-01-2004).]