It's clear that different people are moved by different things. In Gainesville last month, I was on a panel doing open song evaluations.. included on that were Sara Light (our trusted mentor here) who is a total lyric freak. There was an A&R guy from Arista who viewed everything from a commercial point of view.. and a Radio guy who viewed stuff that would appeal to their listening audience.. I focused on the music as that is what first grabs me. It was a great panel and people didn't want to leave when it was over (40 minutes past the end already) because we could all identify and comment on very different things for each song and unlike many panels, it wasn't just lyric or music or commerciality or structure focused.. but covered it all. However, had any of us been alone, we most likely could only have focused on the 1 or 2 things we most felt comfortable with.

It's clear Robert has a strong bias towards music. Though I think he's been a bit impolite, I understand how it gets when everyone else is pounding you on your point and you feel like you have to lash out to support yourself. He's not alone in his thinking, but I think any time you focus on only 1 thing, you're leaving a lot of the puzzle out and without those other pieces.. you don't get a full view of what's going on.

A great song usually has amazing lyrics or an amazing melody or an amazing groove or a fantastic performance combined with at least usable corresponding components. That Norah Jones song that won for song of the year at the Grammy's last year had very weak lyrics, a decent but not amazing melody, a simplistic music track, but a great engaging vocal performance that made two lesser things work. You could easily use that example to say "lyrics aren't important" but then you could take any number of Dylan songs with bad singing, ho hum progressions, no particular groove but brilliant lyrics and make the opposite argument.

So, my advice to Robert is to focus on what his vision is for his music. Find ways to make the melody of your songs so compelling that the lyrics are irrelevant. Others here can write brilliant lyrics that are so good it doesn't matter if it's William Hung performing them. Others can produce slamming music grooves and still others can blow us away with their instrumental prowess.. the ones who make it to the next level of popularity will probably be able to do 2-3 if not all 4 of the above very well.

That's what is so fun about music.. it's so wide open.. and there are so many ways to approach it..

Have fun folks.. and give each other a break.. life is way too short.

Brian


Brian Austin Whitney
Founder
Just Plain Folks
jpfolkspro@gmail.com
Skype: Brian Austin Whitney
Facebook: www.facebook.com/justplainfolks

"Don't sit around and wait for success to come to you... it doesn't know the way." -Brian Austin Whitney

"It's easier to be the bigger man when you actually are..." -Brian Austin Whitney

"Sometimes all you have to do to inspire humans to greatness is to give them a reason and opportunity to do something great." -Brian Austin Whitney