Quote
<font face="Verdana, Arial" size="2">Originally posted by RandyB:
Assuming that the producer makes more money than the director, I would think. [Linked Image]</font>


Naw, it's much more difficult to direct than produce, and there are far fewer directors available. [Linked Image]

But let's finally clear up this misunderstanding that several of the more vocal members seem to attribute to my posts about the economics of the matter.

No one can rightfully claim that merely because someone is famous or rich, that's what makes their art good.

And that's not what I was saying, if one reads what was written rather than jump to conclusions based upon a partial or selective scan.

When I used the names of Webber versus Black, or Bacharach versus David, etc., I was saying that they became famous and rich BECAUSE they were good, not that they were good because they were rich and famous.

What they did as composers was more difficult and apparently more valuable, judging by how they are revered to a greater degree than their lyrical partners, as is nearly always the case with composers versus "lyrics only" collaborators. (and I note again, this is not to say that lyrics are worthless or unimportant... please!)

The fact of fame and riches alone does not, of course, make composers better than their collaborators. The fact they are rewarded with riches and fame to a degree greater than their collaborators is what the point was all about (again IN MOST CASES, NOT ALWAYS!).

Now that that last bone of contention is removed...

Anyone care to venture why even the most casual film goers know the names of directors Martin Scorsese, Francis Ford Coppola, and Steven Spielberg right off the top of their heads, but even the most avid movie buffs probably have to go to the IMDB to find out who produced Raging Bull, Apocalypse Now, and E.T.?

Eh... never mind. [Linked Image]



[This message has been edited by RobertK (edited 03-03-2004).]