I'm a little confused by quite a few posts I've read where people ask for critiques of a "song" they've written--and it turns out to be just words.

I don't mean any disrespect to anyone. I just think it's better to call things what they are if we want to communicate well with each other.

This is my understanding of the correct terminology:

If you write a poem, you are a poet. A poem is intended to be read aloud for best effect.

If you write music, you are a composer.

If you write words and music together, you are a songwriter.

If you take other people's songs and make a new version musically, you are an arranger.

If you write words that are intended to be sung, but you don't write the music for them, you are a lyricist.

I personally have a hard time evaluating a lyric by itself, without hearing the music. Different criteria come into play depending on whether the words are a poem to be read aloud, or a lyric to be sung. So much depends on the melody, the rhythm, the chord progression. How can I decide if the lyric sounds good as part of a song, if the rest of the song is missing? (I'm a singer/songwriter, and I've decided not to critique any lyrics alone on this board because I don't do it well. I end up reading the words like a poem, and I'm afraid my comments will reflect that perspective. I'll leave that up to the lyricists here.)

I have a great deal of respect and admiration for good lyricists. There are many who impress me, in many different styles of writing and styles of music. Just as one example, I think the Gershwin brothers did great together, and Ira's lyrics were so clever, packed with meaning, perfectly rhymed, and a perfect marriage with his brother George's melodies. They were a great songwriting team. However, if I try to read Ira's lyrics as poetry, they don't sound so great--they belong with music, and they fit perfectly with the music they were written for. Just an example.

It seems to me that, in considering the words and the music as two main elements of a song, the music will always be a little more important. Even though the two work together and have an effect on each other (they can be equal, or one can drag the other down or make the other soar), a lyric can only be a part of a song at best, whereas the music can be a song all on its own if the composer wishes.

Any thoughts on this? --JL