Originally Posted by bennash
(Writers) still pitch songs , But yes artists write there own more now , Either with a established (hit writer) or not . like Ashley Gorley ect ect ect.

personal satisfaction ? why yes , cuz 99.99% will never see radio . My buddy just had one picked up by a Nash publisher , maybe 3 weeks ago , I guess it could happen being on radio.

Back on Topic . If a demo studio wrote the melody , they get a % , If AI did the melody , I'm not sure how that would work with publishers , If the writer fed AI with the melody, I'm also not sure on PRO rules on excepting it . I'm guessing this has come up all ready.... with professional publishers and logistics and laws. A Sony Staff writer probably grew up using PRO -Tools , He might have AI in his tool box in 2024. (Slippery Sloap ) I guess .

It has but nobody really knows the answer.

If an ai melody couldn't be used what purpose would it serve? It be useless to anyone thinking professionally.

But there's also the question how would anyone know if an ai melody was used.

Ai detectors maybe, but then the question is who owns what ai generates.

But the truth is as is, right now, udio does the same thing other composer's do, it steals from other composer's.

Which happened in classical music and happens to this day, it just does it so much easier.

If I'm able to use all my own ideas, while using ai as a band, I'd be happy with that.

For rock in my opinion it's not rock without guitars, real guitars, even if the sound is the same, it's power is in knowing yourself what your using, and hopefully that is shown to a listener.

But I do wish for ai as the composer to go away, but stay as a helper

Last edited by Fdemetrio; 06/18/24 08:49 PM.