Judy and Brian, thanks for your perspective on judging these lyrics. I'm in both your camps. On one hand, I'm inclined to reward those lyrics that are exceptional (IMHO) and which fall within the framework of a conventional lyric. Besides the other good reasons that were mentioned, creativity can really come to the fore when one is forced to work within limits. At the same time, I want to pay attention to the unconventional lyric, because if it still moves me in some way, then it is also a good lyric. We are, after all, only "hearing" half the song.

I also agree that these postings should reflect a higher level of polish than say the lyric forums. Bad spelling and editing will costs some of my favorites points off! Thanks for reading.